11 National Scenic Trails Ranked by Difficulty (Guide)

The ranger at Cape Alava looked at my battered boots and shook his head. “You’re the first eastbound PNT hiker we’ve seen this summer who isn’t bleeding from some kind of bushwhack wound.” I wasn’t bleeding—yet—but 1,200 miles of the Pacific Northwest Trail had taught me something that no listicle ever mentioned: National Scenic Trail doesn’t mean what most hikers think it means.

Some of these trails will hand you a continuous wilderness footpath. Others will maroon you on 500 miles of asphalt road walks. Some demand expert mountaineering skills. One is essentially a scenic drive with a few short hiking segments attached. After section-hiking seven of the eleven national scenic trails and researching them all obsessively, I’m convinced that most hikers choose their first long trail based on fame—not fit.

This guide ranks all 11 congressionally designated trails by actual difficulty—not length—using a framework that accounts for physical exertion, technical skills, logistical friction, and objective hazards. Whether you’re choosing your first long-distance hiking trail or completing the entire National Trails System, you’ll know exactly what each trail demands before you commit.

⚡ Quick Answer: The Pacific Northwest Trail is the hardest National Scenic Trail, demanding expert navigation and bushwhacking skills across 1,200 miles with significant road gaps. The Appalachian Trail offers the best infrastructure for first-timers. The Natchez Trace Trail is the easiest, consisting of just 60 miles of disconnected hiking segments. Critically, trails like the Florida Trail (47% road walk) and Ice Age Trail (50% road) are far from continuous wilderness paths—check completion status before planning.

How the 11 National Scenic Trails Got Ranked (And Why Length Doesn’t Equal Difficulty)

The 4-Axis Difficulty Framework

The National Trails System Act of 1968 created the legal framework for two original trails—the Appalachian Trail and Pacific Crest Trail—with nine more added through 2009. But “difficulty” has nothing to do with length. The 4,800-mile North Country National Scenic Trail ranks easier than the 1,200-mile Pacific Northwest National Scenic Trail. Why?

I evaluate each trail across four axes: physical exertion (elevation gain per mile), technical skill (navigation and bushwhacking), logistical friction (resupply frequency and water availability), and hazard exposure (wildlife, weather, and terrain risks). A trail that scores high on all four—like the PNT—demands more from hikers than one that’s simply long.

The famous Triple Crown of hiking—the AT, PCT, and CDT—receives disproportionate media attention. But the lesser-known trails present unique challenges often underestimated by hikers who assume “National Scenic” means groomed wilderness path.

Pro tip: Before committing to any thru-hike, research the trail’s completion percentage. A “scenic trail” that’s 47% pavement changes everything about your gear, your budget, and your sanity.

Why “Completion Status” Changes Everything

Here’s the information that most trail guides bury or ignore: only the Appalachian Trail offers a 100% protected, continuous footpath. Every other National Scenic Trail has gaps requiring road walks or detours.

The numbers are sobering. The Florida National Scenic Trail is approximately 47% paved road walking or non-trail path. The Ice Age National Scenic Trail is about 50% connecting road routes. The North Country Trail has over 1,500 miles (33%) on pavement. According to the North Country Trail 2024 Progress Report, only about 3,321 miles are actual off-road trail.

Road walks introduce unique hazards: vehicle traffic, heat radiating from asphalt, and a psychological monotony that breaks hikers faster than mountains do. Your gear changes too—running-style shoes with more cushion become essential for road-heavy trails.

The Expert Tier: Trails That Demand Mountaineering Skills

Rank #1: Pacific Northwest Trail—The Mountaineer’s Bushwhack (1,200 mi)

The Pacific Northwest Trail runs from Chief Mountain in Glacier National Park to Cape Alava on Washington’s Olympic coast. Founder Ron Strickland pioneered the route in the 1970s; it wasn’t designated until 2009. That late designation tells you something—this trail was too wild to tame.

Mile-for-mile, the PNT is the most demanding National Scenic Trail. It gains and loses over 210,000 feet of elevation in just 1,200 miles—a steeper average gradient than the PCT. But elevation isn’t the core challenge. The trail lacks the manicured tread of established routes. Hikers describe “soul-crushing bushwhacks” through the Selkirk and Kettle River ranges, overgrown sections requiring physical pushing through dense vegetation, and “lost trail” conditions where route-finding skills matter more than fitness.

Objective hazards compound the difficulty. The trail transects Yaak Valley and Glacier National Park—critical grizzly bear habitat. Carrying bear spray isn’t optional; it’s survival equipment. The trail’s narrow weather window (July through September) overlaps perfectly with wildfire season, forcing annual reroutes. Know your bear spray deployment fundamentals before you set foot on this trail.

Hiker Profile: Solitary Expert / Navigator. This trail rewards self-reliance over pure fitness.

Rank #2: Continental Divide Trail—The Wildest of the Triple Crown (3,100 mi)

The Continental Divide Trail stretches approximately 3,100 miles from Crazy Cook Monument on the Mexican border to Waterton Lakes in Canada. Designated in 1978, it remains only 70-95% complete depending on how you define “trail”—roughly 69% is on optimal single-track.

The CDT operates largely above treeline, exposing hikers to daily lightning hazards and extreme weather shifts. Water carries in the Great Divide Basin (Wyoming) and New Mexico can stretch 20-30 miles between sources, demanding careful planning and high-capacity water storage.

Budget reality hits hard here. Average cost runs $8,900+ based on 2023 data, likely pushing $10,000+ with current inflation. Resupply points are infrequent, often requiring expensive shuttles or mail drops to remote towns weeks in advance. Master your resupply box logistics before attempting this trail.

The CDT culture differs from other trails. “Embrace the Alternate” is a community mantra. Unlike the AT’s single white-blazed path, the CDT rewards hikers who create their own adventure, choosing between routes like the Gila River alternate versus the Black Range.

The Advanced Tier: Long-Distance Endurance Tests

Rank #3: Pacific Crest Trail—The Endurance Marathon (2,650 mi)

The Pacific Crest Trail runs 2,650 miles from Campo, California, to Manning Park, British Columbia. As one of the original two National Scenic Trails (1968), it’s nearly 100% protected corridor with about 90% actual trail.

The PCT is graded for pack stock (horses), meaning steep climbs are mitigated by switchbacks rather than fall lines. The physical challenge comes from sheer distance and the High Sierra altitude—Forester Pass tops out at 13,200 feet. In high snow years, the Sierra Nevada demands ice axe skills and crampon proficiency.

Wildfire smoke and trail closures are now guaranteed parts of the PCT experience. Plan for section skips. Cost reality has shifted dramatically: expect $8,000 to $12,000 for a thru-hike, driven by expensive West Coast towns and gear replacement every 500 miles.

Rank #4: Appalachian Trail—The Physical Grind (2,198 mi)

The Appalachian Trail covers 2,198 miles from Springer Mountain, Georgia, to Mount Katahdin, Maine. Benton MacKaye conceived the trail in 1921; it was designated in 1968. It’s famously steep—”PUDs” (Pointless Ups and Downs) total +464,500 feet of elevation gain without the switchbacks common on western trails.

But here’s why it’s the best choice for first-timers: it’s the only fully continuous footpath in the National Trails System. Towns appear every 3-4 days. Cell signal is reliable. The trail angels and trail magic culture provides an unmatched support network. If something goes wrong, help is never far.

Average cost runs $6,000-$8,000, though “Platinum Blazing”—frequent hotel stays—can push totals over $10,000. The AT is a social trail. If you want solitude, look elsewhere; you’ll see the same 50 hikers every day.

Pro tip: The AT’s “Vortex” is real—trail towns that trap you for multiple days of zero miles. Budget extra for the psychological pull of hot showers and real food.

Rank #5: Arizona Trail—The Desert Extremes (800 mi)

The Arizona Trail spans 800 miles from Coronado National Memorial near Mexico to the Utah border. Teacher Dale Shewalter envisioned it in 1985; it was designated in 2009. At roughly 99% complete, it offers a continuous experience unlike road-heavy trails.

Water management defines the Arizona National Scenic Trail. Caching water in dry “Sky Islands” sectors is mandatory. The trail crosses the Grand Canyon rim-to-rim—one of the most demanding single-day vertical efforts on any National Scenic Trail. Mandatory gear includes a sun umbrella, 4-6 liter water capacity, and tweezers for removing cholla cactus spines. An electrolyte strategy for desert hiking is non-negotiable.

Hiker Profile: Desert Technician / Ultralight. This trail rewards heat management skills over pure stamina.

The Moderate Tier: Fragmented Trails With Hidden Challenges

Rank #6: North Country Trail—The Horizontal Giant (4,800 mi)

At 4,800 miles, the North Country National Scenic Trail is the longest in the system, stretching from Lake Sakakawea, North Dakota, to Green Mountain National Forest, Vermont. But only about 3,321 miles are off-road trail; over 1,500 miles are road walks.

The terrain is gentler—glaciated plains and lake shores rather than mountains—but sheer endurance and the fragmented nature create unique friction. The trail incorporates existing routes like the Superior Hiking Trail and the Finger Lakes Trail.

Hazards here differ from western trails. Ticks carrying Lyme disease are prevalent across Wisconsin, Minnesota, New York, and Pennsylvania. Use a comprehensive tick prevention system religiously. Hunting seasons require blaze orange clothing. Vehicle traffic on road sections is a constant danger.

Pro tip: Contact local trail chapters for shuttle coordination—the North Country Trail Association volunteer network is exceptionally helpful for navigating the fragmented sections.

Rank #7: New England Trail (215 mi) and Rank #8: Ice Age Trail (1,200 mi)

The New England National Scenic Trail runs 215 miles from Guilford, Connecticut, to Royalston, Massachusetts. Despite its short length, steep trap rock ridges deliver +30,000 feet of total gain. Camping is restricted to only about 9 designated sites, forcing reliance on off-trail lodging. A 10-mile road walk crosses the Connecticut River. It’s perfect as a “shakedown” hike before the AT.

The Ice Age National Scenic Trail traces Wisconsin’s glacial moraine for 1,200 miles, but only ~675 miles are yellow-blazed trail—roughly 50% is road. Ray Zillmer envisioned this “long linear park” in the 1950s. Best hiked in autumn to avoid intense mosquito pressure. Permethrin-treated gear is essential in the glacial pothole wetlands.

The Accessible Tier: Trails for Every Skill Level

Rank #9: Potomac Heritage Trail—The Braided Network (710 mi)

The Potomac Heritage National Scenic Trail isn’t a single footpath—it’s a network including the C&O Canal Towpath, Mount Vernon Trail, and Laurel Highlands. It’s the only National Scenic Trail where cycling a significant portion is a primary use case. Allows multi-modal travel: hike, bike, and paddle segments. Highly fragmented with gaps in Northern Virginia requiring detours.

Rank #10: Florida Trail—The Swamp Slog (1,500 mi)

The Florida National Scenic Trail runs 1,500 miles from Big Cypress National Preserve to Gulf Islands National Seashore. Elevation change is essentially zero—less than 300 feet total—but the environment fights back. Jim Kern founded the Florida Trail Association in 1966; the trail was designated in 1983.

The critical reality: approximately 47% of the route is paved road walking. Hikers wade through thigh-deep swamp water in Big Cypress. Expect wet feet for days. Hazards include alligators (constant vigilance near water), venomous snakes like the Eastern Diamondback, and heat exhaustion. Mandatory gear: snake gaiters, sun umbrella, water filtration for tannic swamp water. Know your snakebite protocol before heading south.

Rank #11: Natchez Trace Trail—The Historic Walk (60 mi)

The Natchez Trace National Scenic Trail is not a continuous thru-hike. It consists of five disconnected hiking segments totaling approximately 60 miles, paralleling the 444-mile Natchez Trace Parkway scenic drive. It commemorates the historic travel corridor used by Indigenous peoples and 19th-century “Kaintucks.” Best for day hikers and history buffs. Walking the road shoulder between segments is dangerous and discouraged.

Budgeting Reality: What Each Trail Actually Costs in 2026

Thru-Hike Cost Breakdown by Trail

The “$1,000 per month” rule is obsolete. Costs have risen 30-55% since the 2019 data that still dominates search results.

Current realistic estimates: PCT runs $8,000-$12,000 (expensive West Coast towns, gear replacement every 500 miles). AT costs $6,000-$8,000 (frequent town stops, hostel inflation). CDT demands $8,000-$10,000 (remote shuttles, high gear wear). Florida Trail runs $3,500-$5,000 (shorter duration but high daily burn—hotels over hostels). Arizona Trail is more affordable at $2,000-$3,500 (6-8 weeks, water caching costs). Pre-hike gear investment averages $2,000+ (Dyneema/DCF inflation)—often excluded from “on-trail” budgets. Review a solid budget gear strategy before your first major purchase.

According to The Trek’s cost analysis, AT costs have surged significantly post-2020, with the average now pushing $7,600.

The “Town Trap” Phenomenon

Trail life costs about $15/day for food. But zero days in town average $100+ (motel, restaurant, resupply, laundry). On the AT, towns appear every 3-4 days—temptation is constant. “Platinum Blazing” (frequent hotel stays) is the number one budget killer for first-time thru-hikers. Pre-determine your town stops on your itinerary. Unplanned nero days drain budgets fast.

Pro tip: Hiker boxes at hostels are free gear and food—check them before resupplying at inflated trail-town prices.

Conclusion

Three points to remember before you choose your trail:

Length ≠ Difficulty. The 1,200-mile Pacific Northwest Trail demands more from hikers than the 4,800-mile North Country Trail. Match your skills to the trail’s actual demands—navigation, heat management, bushwhacking—not just mileage.

Check Completion Status First. If you’re dreaming of wilderness areas and pristine hiking trails, know that the Florida Trail is 47% pavement. The Ice Age Trail is half road. Plan your experience accordingly.

Budget for 2026, Not 2019. Costs have surged 30-55%. The PCT isn’t a $6,000 hike anymore—it’s $10,000+. Financial failure ends more thru-hikes than physical failure.

Every National Scenic Trail offers something unique—glacial geology in Wisconsin, subtropical swamps in Florida, alpine grandeur on the CDT. The best scenic trail for you isn’t the most famous one; it’s the one that matches your current skill set and stretches you just enough to grow.

Risk Disclaimer: Hiking, trekking, backpacking, and all related outdoor activities involve inherent risks which may result in serious injury, illness, or death. The information provided on The Hiking Tribe is for educational and informational purposes only. While we strive for accuracy, information on trails, gear, techniques, and safety is not a substitute for your own best judgment and thorough preparation. Trail conditions, weather, and other environmental factors change rapidly and may differ from what is described on this site. Always check with official sources like park services for the most current alerts and conditions. Never undertake a hike beyond your abilities and always be prepared for the unexpected. By using this website, you agree that you are solely responsible for your own safety. Any reliance you place on our content is strictly at your own risk, and you assume all liability for your actions and decisions in the outdoors. The Hiking Tribe and its authors will not be held liable for any injury, damage, or loss sustained in connection with the use of the information herein.

Affiliate Disclosure: We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. We also participate in other affiliate programs and may receive a commission on products purchased through our links, at no extra cost to you. Additional terms are found in the terms of service.